28 May 2012

Introduction by Klaatu

I am Klaatu. 

Not so long ago, I was sent by the Planets to bring a message to the peoples of the planet called Earth. As has happened many times before, a planet’s people was about to make its first steps towards leaving its home and, following our protocols, a patrol ship and first contact agent was sent to meet those people. I was the agent, and was accompanied by patrol robot Gort.

Unlike most other planets at the time they begin their first extraterrestrial steps, the civilizations of Earth are socially more simple and violent. Once our ship landed in the capitol city of their major nuclear power, we allowed the residents several hours to adjust to our landing before we attempted to deliver our message. They mobilized a large and formidable group of military personnel and equipment that, I had supposed, would give them some sense of security in the presence of our technology. In that assumption I was quite wrong.

I departed the craft and made the announcement that we came to visit in peace and with good intentions. As I withdrew the gift I had brought for the nation’s president, a single soldier panicked and shot me with a bullet. Army seniors took me to the Walter Reed Hospital where I recovered and also had time to meet with the secretary to the president of the United States of America. I informed him that I had brought a message of vital concern to all living things on Earth, and that the message must be delivered to all peoples – or their representatives – simultaneously. Though the president agreed to issue invitations to such a meeting, the petty squabbles among the peoples and their nations prevented such a meeting from taking place. One government would not meet in Washington, another would not meet in Moscow, and yet others would not attend any meeting at with the others would be present. Incredible as it may seem now, human leaders were more repelled by their mutual dislike and distrust than they were intrigued to learn what message was behind the first contact between their planet and an intelligent extraterrestrial race.

In desperation I sought out Earth’s most prominent scientist, and got him to agree to gather a meeting of the leading minds from all nations. In order to convince people of the power and thereby the gravity of my message, that scientist asked that I arrange some sort of dramatic but non-destructive demonstration. In the event, I arranged to shut down all non-vital electrical power on Earth for a period of 30 minutes. As per our protocols, which strictly ban endangering any life, power was maintained for air vehicles in flight, hospitals, emergency equipment, and other such devices. The demonstration was extremely effective in suggesting to the Earth people just how much power a single ship could deliver, but in a socially aggressive culture such as seen on Earth a display is interpreted as a challenge to try to overcome that power. Earth officials decided I must be caught and executed, and they shot me dead an hour before the scheduled meeting with the scientists and other scholars.

Through the assistance of a brave and intellectually aware Earth woman, Gort was restrained from destroying Earth, but instead recovered and regenerated my body. So far, I am still quite functional. I was able to attend the scheduled meeting just as the people were starting to disburse, and at that time I gave them our message. Gort and I then returned to the ship and began the journey home.

As we left the Earth, I was pondering the conditions that would allow creatures capable of such wonderful achievements to behave as they do. Among the truly awe inspiring accomplishments have been the music of Mozart and Beethoven, the eclectic genius of Da Vinci, the depth of insight of Socrates, Rousseau, and Voltaire, and the ability to observe and critically evaluate humanity as demonstrated by Aristotle, Jefferson, and Wells. There is no doubt that people are aware of the vile and reprehensible acts of aggression and violence they routinely practice, and there is considerable objection to those actions. Why, then, do those actions continue and expand? This is a question that I feel cannot be answered in short and simple terms and still hold meaning. Indeed, the overarching power of short and pithy, if less than informative, “sound bites” has become the most widely accepted form of news and factual information for much of Earth’s population. Combine the limited value that comes from a one or two sentence statement with the ease with which such statements can be presented out of context such that they are totally distorted, and it becomes easier to understand why humanity has so little real grasp of either its mass power or the factors affecting them all. Any species that would so thoroughly fail to respond to the crisis of having its two frozen poles melting seems, to me, beyond the ability to effectively understand. Perhaps humanity is simply more prone to self-destruction than it is to survival and advancement. Only time will tell.

Still following protocol, I have continued to observe Earth activities to determine how the people would respond to our message. In this, I have acted in the capacity of a behavioral biologist, with elements of ecologist added. The species has been predictable, having achieved very rudimentary space flight capability and, as we feared, sent nuclear materials into space. So far, at least, the ability for humans to take a controlled, manned spacecraft effectively out of orbit does not yet exist, although robot probes have been launched with increasing frequency over the past several years. Not surprisingly, when one of our police ships destroyed one of their Martian probes, it was not reported as a warning but as a mistake in programming between their metric and imperial measurement systems. 

As required by our laws, I am now providing my detailed report on Earth, its people, and my judgment on their suitability – or lack thereof – to join the races and peoples of the other planets. What follows is my judgment and the evidence I have used in coming to that judgment.

PREFACE

On a spring day in 1951 a spacecraft arrived on Earth carrying an envoy from “the other planets.” The very human-looking alien, Klaatu, bore a message intended for all the peoples of the Earth, a message upon which depends the fate of the planet. Klaatu set out to mingle and learn something of the nature of human aggressiveness, but fearful authorities sought him out and shot him dead. He was, however, resurrected by his formidable giant robot companion, Gort. Finally, and all too briefly, the understandably annoyed Klaatu addressed a hastily gathered audience of intellectuals. 

Earth, he said, had begun experimenting with atomic power and space travel. If humans continued on their historical course and bring the threat of atomic war off their small world, they would threaten the peace of the other planets. “This cannot be allowed,” Klaatu warned, and “if you threaten to extend your violence,” there would be no choice left but to reduce the world into “a burned out cinder.” “We shall be waiting for your answer,” he declared. “The decision rests with you.” 

With that he and Gort returned to their space ship and left. What would happen next? 

There seems little doubt that Klaatu would submit a detailed situation report upon returning home. In Klaatu’s Judgment, a professional biologist anticipates what Klaatu—or any other intelligent alien observer—would have to say about humanity and its potential for joining the peaceful assembly of other planets. Why are people so enmeshed in war and other violent behaviors? Are there any common threads that link aggressiveness across the bounds of race, culture, and level of societal development? Above all, do humans have the capacity or ability to abandon aggression? 

Zoologist Robert Sprackland answers these questions as Klaatu might, by looking at human societies through the eyes of a scientist aiming to explain human behavior with the same tools and models that he would explain the behavior of any other animal species. Is there something so basic to our biology that stepping away from suspicion and violence is simply not yet part of our developmental evolution? In Klaatu’s Judgment, Sprackland brings forth example after example to document a pattern that has gone unchanged since the beginning of written histories, and delivers a hypothetical outcome that forces us to face the idea that we have the intellect to make the jump to peace, but may not have the emotional stability to keep us from turning our own planet into that “burned out cinder.” 

 [“Klaatu” is the name of a fictional character depicted in the short story "Farewell to the Master," by Harry Bates (1940). What follows here is not a work of fiction but a commentary. The author claims no copyright for use of the term “Klaatu” or references to the film, The Day the Earth Stood Still, by Edmund North. Otherwise, the text is copyright© 2008, 2012 by Robert George Sprackland. All rights reserved.]